Colossians 2:20

The Text

Paul asks a question with a hook in it. You died with Christ, he says, and that death cut you loose from the elements of the world, the whole apparatus of religious regulation that once told you what to eat, when to fast, which days to honor. So why do you keep behaving as though you still live under that regime, letting yourself be enrolled in ordinances all over again? The verse is not a statement but an interrogation, and the sting is in the word "why." Paul does not argue that the rules are false; he argues that they no longer have jurisdiction over a corpse. Someone who has been buried with Christ has stepped outside their reach.

The Core

Everything here rests on a fact that has already happened: "you died with Christ." Not you should die, not you are dying, but you died, past tense, settled at baptism, when you were joined to the death that stripped the principalities and powers. That death changed your address. The elements of the world, whatever combination of religious duty, cultural expectation and cosmic fear once ruled you, still exist; they simply have no legal claim on the dead. What Paul attacks is not discipline but the instinct that our standing must be earned by keeping ourselves clean. Grace is not the removal of moral seriousness. It is the removal of the accounting system, the handwriting nailed to the cross, so that obedience becomes gratitude rather than payment.

The Common Thread

Paul's logic runs along a line that stretches back through the whole story. Israel was brought out of slavery first and given the law second; the commandments were the shape of a freedom already granted, not the price of it. When Paul calls the feast days and new moons "a shadow of the things to come; but the body is Christ's," he is saying that the whole regulatory apparatus was always pointing forward, a silhouette cast by someone who had not yet walked into the room. Now he has. To return to shadow-management after the body has arrived is not piety but confusion about what time it is. The cross did not adjust the terms of the old arrangement; it ended it, publicly, stripping the powers that enforced it and making a spectacle of them.

The Mirror

You know the mechanism even if you would never call it religion. The quiet ledger you keep about how many mornings you actually opened the Bible this week. The way you feel more presentable before God after a week of eating well and less so after the takeaway and the second glass. The unspoken code in your church about alcohol, or screens, or how a Christian family spends Sunday afternoon, and the small superiority you feel when you are on the right side of it. The exhaustion of parenting by other people's rules. Paul's question lands on all of it: why, having died, do you keep submitting yourself for inspection? Not because the habits are worthless, but because you have handed them an authority they cannot bear. Take ten minutes: write on a piece of paper the one rule you keep in order to feel acceptable, the real one, in your own words. Then write across it, in capitals, NO JURISDICTION. Tear it up before the day ends.

The Question

If we died to ordinances, what stops this from becoming an excuse? Paul knows the objection and does not fully soothe it. He ends the paragraph with something almost bleak: these practices "aren't of any value against the indulgence of the flesh." Rules do not work. But he does not then hand us a technique that does. He gives us a person and a location: hold firmly to the Head. That leaves a genuine difficulty, because the line between a discipline that serves love and an ordinance that governs you is not drawn in the practice itself but somewhere in the heart, where you cannot always see clearly. The honest test is who is watching. If you fast to be free, keep going. If you fast so that someone, including yourself, will finally issue a verdict, you have crawled back into the courtroom Christ emptied.

The Detail

The verb behind "do you subject yourselves to ordinances" is dogmatizesthe, and it is not active. It means something closer to: why do you let yourself be decreed at, why do you stand there and receive the regulations? Paul does not accuse the Colossians of inventing the rules. Someone else is doing that, the person with the persuasive speech, the one who judges them about eating and drinking. Their sin is consent. That is uncomfortably familiar, because most of our bondage is not chosen but absorbed, from a family, a workplace culture, a church tradition, an algorithm that tells you daily what a serious person eats and buys and worries about. The dead are not asked to fight these voices. They are simply outside the range of their instruction.

The Intertext

Romans 6 says the same thing with the same grammar of past tense: baptized into his death, therefore reckon yourselves dead to sin. Paul never treats this as a feeling to be achieved; it is a fact to be calculated with, the way you calculate with a paid-off debt. Galatians 4 supplies the other half, where Paul is astonished that people who came to know God are turning back to what he calls weak and beggarly elements, and then names the symptom: observing days and months and seasons. Both letters describe the same reflex. Freedom is disorienting, and the human heart would rather have a syllabus than a Savior. Paul's answer is never a better syllabus. It is a funeral you have already attended, and a Head you are still attached to.

Reflection

Which rule, if you broke it tomorrow, would make you feel unacceptable to God, and where did that rule actually come from?

Where in your life are you letting someone else issue verdicts that the cross has already overruled, and what would it cost you to stop asking for their approval?

Go deeper in Colossians

Hand picked books that unpack this Bible book further.

Paul For Everyone: The Prison Letters

N.T. Wright

Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians and Philemon in short daily readings.

Read on Kobo →

Colossians and Philemon: An Introduction and Commentary

N.T. Wright

A trusted Tyndale commentary: compact, careful and clear on every passage.

Read on Kobo →

Colossians and Philemon

David Garland

Explains what it meant then, and bridges it honestly to life now.

Read on Kobo →

The Message of Colossians and Philemon

Dick Lucas

Christ above everything: fullness in him against every substitute.

Read on Kobo →

Faith.network earns a small commission on Kobo purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. It helps keep the studies free.