Isaiah 65:17

The Text

Right after the announcement that the old griefs are "hidden from my eyes" (v. 16), God speaks a sentence that sounds too large for its context: he is making new heavens and a new earth. Not repairing, not renovating, but creating. And the consequence follows immediately: everything that came before, the whole weight of what happened, will not be remembered, will not even rise into anyone's mind again. What follows in verses 18 and 19 makes plain what kind of newness this is, because the first thing named is not architecture but atmosphere: Jerusalem as a delight, her people a joy, and the sound of weeping gone from her streets.

The Core

The verb behind "create" is bara, the word used in Genesis 1 and reserved in Hebrew for what only God does. That is the whole claim in one word. The returned exiles were living in a city they had rebuilt themselves, stone by stone, with foreign permission and imperial money, and the result was thin: a modest temple, a small population, factions accusing each other of impurity, as verse 5 shows with its cutting quotation of the man who says "Stay by yourself, don't come near to me, for I am holier than you." God does not promise to bless that project harder. He announces an act on the scale of the first morning of the world. Salvation here is not improvement of what exists but the making of something that does not yet exist, which means it cannot be earned, organized, or hurried by anyone in that city.

The Common Thread

The word bara pulls a thread taut across the whole Bible. It appears on the first page, where God makes heaven and earth, and it appears here, at the far end of Israel's disaster, where God announces that he will do it again. Between those two points lies everything that went wrong. What Isaiah is saying is that the story does not end with repair work on the ruins of the first creation; it ends with a second act of the same magnitude. The New Testament picks this up without hesitation. When Paul says that anyone in Christ is a new creation, he is not reaching for a metaphor of personal improvement, he is claiming that the thing Isaiah announced has begun in one man's raised body. Easter is the first square metre of the new earth.

The Mirror

Isaiah is not speaking to people who need a mood lift. He is speaking to people who have buried infants, who have planted and watched someone else harvest, who lost a generation to an army. Read verses 21 to 23 and you see exactly which griefs were on the table. Yours are probably different in shape: the diagnosis, the years given to a job that dropped you, the child who does not call, the marriage that never became what you promised each other at the front of the church. Isaiah does not tell you those things were not that bad. He tells you they will not be remembered, which is a far stranger and far larger comfort, because it assumes they are heavy enough to need removing. Today: write on a scrap of paper the one thing you would most want lifted out of your memory, say the words "I create new heavens and a new earth" out loud over it, and keep the paper where you will find it again.

The Intertext

Two places light this verse up. The first is Genesis 1, not for its details but for its verb; by using bara Isaiah refuses to let anyone hear this as restoration of the good old days under David. The second is the last two chapters of Revelation, where John sees new heavens and a new earth and a city in which God wipes the tears away and death is finished. John is not inventing; he is reading Isaiah 65 and reporting that he has seen it. The difference is telling. Isaiah's new world still has death in it, only pushed to the far edge (verse 20). John's does not. The promise widens as the story moves forward.

The Profile

Picture the audience. A provincial town in the Persian empire, perhaps a few thousand people, walls still gapped, a temple that the older men remembered weeping over because it was so much smaller than the one Nebuchadnezzar burned. Taxes flowed out toward Susa. Harvests were unreliable. Somewhere on the edge of town a table stood set with mixed wine for Fortune and Destiny (verse 11), because when the covenant God seems slow, luck is a reasonable investment. In that dusty, disappointed, quarrelling place, someone reads out that God is making new heavens and a new earth. It would have sounded absurd. That is precisely the point: the promise is measured against God's capacity, not the town's.

The Question

Can God simply un-remember? The text says the former things will not "come into mind", and something in us resists that. If my grief is erased, is the person I lost erased too? Does the sixty-year-old wound that shaped everything about me just get deleted, and with it me? Isaiah does not answer. Hebrew "remembering" is active rather than mental, closer to holding on to something, so not-remembering may mean the past loses its grip rather than its existence. But the verse says more than that, and I will not shave it down to fit. The best I can say is that a God who can make a new heaven can be trusted with what to keep.

Reflection

Which former thing in your life do you secretly believe God cannot make new, only manage?

If salvation is creation rather than repair, what does that change about what you are trying to fix by effort this week?

Go deeper in Isaiah

Hand picked books that unpack this Bible book further.

Isaiah (Tyndale Old Testament Commentaries)

Alec Motyer

A lifetime of Isaiah study distilled into one accessible volume.

Read on Kobo →

The Message of Isaiah

Barry Webb

Keeps the big storyline of judgment and comfort wonderfully clear.

Read on Kobo →

Isaiah: An Introduction and Commentary

Alec Motyer

A lifetime of Isaiah study distilled into one accessible volume.

Read on Kobo →

Isaiah

John Oswalt

Explains what it meant then, and bridges it honestly to life now.

Read on Kobo →

Isaiah For You

Tim Chester

The gospel according to Isaiah in short readable steps.

Read on Kobo →

Faith.network earns a small commission on Kobo purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. It helps keep the studies free.