John 11:56

The Text

Passover is close, and Jerusalem is filling up with pilgrims who have come early to purify themselves. Standing around in the temple courts, they keep an eye out for one particular man and turn the question over among themselves: "What do you think—that he isn't coming to the feast at all?" It is the talk of a crowd that knows an arrest warrant has been issued, knows what happened at Bethany, and cannot decide whether to expect a prophet or a corpse.

Picture the noise of it. Tens of thousands of bodies pressed into the outer court, the bleating of lambs held for inspection, the smell of blood and smoke drifting from the altar, moneychangers calling rates, dust hanging in the spring light. And in the middle of all that liturgical machinery, small knots of people scanning faces at the gates, asking each other the one question nobody in authority wants asked out loud.

The Core

This is a verse about a crowd that wants Jesus present without wanting to be committed to him. Notice the grammar of their question: it is speculation, not seeking. They ask one another, not God, and they ask what they think, which is the safest thing a person can risk in a temple full of informers. John has just told us the chief priests gave orders that anyone who knew where he was should report it. So this whispering is curiosity with the volume turned down, faith hedged into gossip.

That matters theologically, because John's whole Gospel presses one demand: decision. Martha, a few verses earlier, was asked point blank, "Do you believe this?" and answered with her whole self. The crowd in the temple is asked nothing and answers nothing. They are interested. Interest, John keeps showing us, is not belief. It is the most comfortable place in the world to stand, and it is precisely where the light does not reach.

The Common Thread

The crowd's question has an answer they cannot guess. Yes, he is coming to the feast, and not as a pilgrim slipping through a side gate. They have come up early to purify themselves, because contact with a corpse or a grave left a person unfit to eat the Passover, and the rites took days. So here is the irony John builds with a straight face: thousands of people scrubbing themselves clean for a lamb, wondering whether the man who just walked into a tomb and called a dead man out will dare show his face. Caiaphas has already said more than he knew, "it is advantageous for us that one man should die for the people." The feast that the crowd is preparing for is the feast that is preparing for him. Every lamb inspected in that court is a rehearsal.

The Mirror

There is a particular kind of religious life that consists entirely of talking about Jesus with other people. You discuss him in the small group, you assess the sermon on the drive home, you have opinions about what he would say to the church, to the country, to your brother-in-law. It is genuine interest and it costs nothing. The temple crowd is not cynical; they are curious, even hopeful. But they have learned to keep their hope in the conditional, because in that city an unguarded sentence could be reported. We have our own reasons: the colleague who would file us under a category, the family table where certain things are no longer said, the fear of being the one who takes it too seriously. So: take the question you have been asking about Jesus only in the third person, the one you have been kicking around with other people, and say it to him directly, out loud, in the next ten minutes. Second person. Not "what do you think" but "what are you doing".

The Detail

The Greek behind "that he isn't coming to the feast at all?" is shaped to expect the answer no. They are not wondering; they are predicting, and predicting the cautious thing. Of course he won't come. Would you? A wanted man with a price on his whereabouts, walking into the most heavily policed square in Judea at the most heavily policed week of the year. Their question is really a shrug dressed as speculation. And that is the quiet sting of the verse. The crowd underestimates him in exactly the direction we all underestimate him: they assume he will do what self-preservation requires. John lets the assumption stand for one verse, and then the rest of the Gospel dismantles it.

Context

The scene sits between two chapters of hardening. Jesus has withdrawn to Ephraim, on the dry edge of the wilderness, after the council in Jerusalem resolved on his death. Passover swelled the city many times over; Roman troops moved up from Caesarea to the Antonia fortress precisely because festivals bred riots, and the high priestly family knew that one messianic surge could bring the legions down on temple and nation together. That is the fear behind verse 48. So the temple courts in these days were not only holy ground but contested ground, watched by temple police and Roman eyes alike, thick with rumour about the Galilean and the man from Bethany who had been dead four days.

The Profile

John's first readers, decades later, knew what the crowd in the court did not. They knew he came. They also knew, many of them, what it felt like to stand in a public place where naming Jesus carried a cost, in a synagogue or a market or before a magistrate, and to lower the voice, and to ask a neighbour rather than confess. This verse would have read to them like a mirror held up at an uncomfortable angle: here are people close enough to the truth to be talking about it, and still outside it. John does not mock them. He simply shows that the distance between the temple court and Martha's confession is not information. It is nerve.

Reflection

Where in your week do you speak about Jesus in the third person, comfortably, with people who will not press you, and where would speaking in the second person cost you something?

The crowd assumed he would not come because coming was dangerous. What have you quietly assumed God will not do, because doing it would be costly or unreasonable?

Go deeper in John

Hand picked books that unpack this Bible book further.

The Message of John

Bruce Milne

A rich, clear companion to John's portrait of Jesus.

Read on Kobo →

Encounters with Jesus

Timothy Keller

Conversations from John's Gospel that answer life's biggest questions.

Read on Kobo →

John: An Introduction and Commentary

Colin Kruse

A trusted Tyndale commentary: compact, careful and clear on every passage.

Read on Kobo →

John

Gary Burge

Explains what it meant then, and bridges it honestly to life now.

Read on Kobo →

John For Everyone, Part 1

N.T. Wright

Accessible passage by passage help for the most loved Gospel.

Read on Kobo →

Faith.network earns a small commission on Kobo purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. It helps keep the studies free.